TIAA 401(k) Review: A 3% Match, a $43 Price Tag, and a Menu Built on Its Own Annuities
TIAA pays 100% of the first 3% of base salary you put in. That is a clean 3% ceiling on employer money, and at the $360,000 pay cap for 2026 it comes to $10,800. The full rule text sits on the plan’s MyPlanIQ plan info page, and the maximum match calculator turns that 3% into dollars at your own salary, both biweekly and for the year.
Three percent is a smaller employer ceiling than most of the plans we review, where dollar for dollar on the first 5% or 6% is common. The other side of the ledger is where this plan stands out. It costs 1.14 basis points to run, about $43 per participant, and 99.6% of the people who are eligible use it. TIAA is the company that writes retirement plans for colleges, hospitals and research institutions. Its own 401(k) is an interesting test of what that advice looks like when the employer pays for it.
What the 3% ceiling pays at different salaries
The match buys one dollar for every dollar you contribute, up to 3% of base salary. Below are the numbers at a few pay levels:
At $60,000 of salary, 3% is $1,800 and the match is $1,800. At $90,000, you put in $2,700 and TIAA puts in $2,700. At $150,000, the pair is $4,500 each. At $250,000, it is $7,500 each. At the $360,000 compensation cap, you put in $10,800 and the plan matches $10,800.
On the money inside the 3% line, the return is 100%. Every dollar above 3% of pay earns nothing extra. The plan lets you defer up to 100% of base salary or the annual IRS limit, whichever is lower. The policy summary in the plan’s public filings still quotes $20,500 as the annual limit, which is from an older version of the document, so ask HR for the current figure. For 2026 the employee limit is $24,500, with catch-up contributions on top for people 50 and older.
The percentage cap is what binds here, not the dollar cap. Three percent of the $360,000 compensation cap is $10,800, well under the $24,500 deferral limit. Nobody loses match money by hitting the IRS limit early in the year. A plan that matches dollar for dollar on 6% would pay $21,600 at that same salary, still under the limit. So the difference between this plan and a 6% design is real money, not a timing artifact.
The plan in numbers
The 2024 public filings report $43,660,020 of employer money going into participant accounts, against $251,304,102 of total contributions. Employer money was 17.4% of everything that went in. The published employer match rate is 28.08% of employee contributions. That number reads low, and the reason is on the employee side, not the employer side.
At the end of 2024 the plan held $4,624,423,064 in assets across 26,861 reported participants, for an average account value of $172,161. The average employee contribution was $5,978 and the average employer match was $1,625. Asset growth for the year was 11.44% and the estimated aggregate investment gain was 12.24%. The plan level investment and administrative expense ratio was 0.01%. The plan was established in 1998.
Our plan rating page scores it 81.14 out of 100, with a rank of 905 out of 9,416 plans. Total cost is 1.14 basis points, which works out to about $43 per participant, and the cost score is 97.06. The employer generosity score is 43.8. That split is the story of this plan: it is one of the cheapest plans we score and one of the thinner ones on employer money.
Why participation is high and employer money is low
The participation rate is 99.6%, which puts the plan in the top 5% of the plans we score. The average deferral per active participant is $13,493, which is top 10%. The employer contribution per active participant is $3,788, which is top half. People at TIAA save. The plan design just stops paying at a low line.
You can see the shape of it in two divisions. Divide the $3,788 of employer money per active participant by 3% and you get about $126,000 of average matched pay. Divide the $13,493 average deferral by that same pay and the typical active participant is saving about 10.7% of salary. That means roughly 7.7 points of pay go in every year above the match line and earn no employer money. The 28.08% match ratio is arithmetic, not a sign that employees are leaving the match on the table. The typical saver collects all of it and then keeps going.
The other number worth knowing: $43,660,020 of employer money divided by $3,788 per active participant implies about 11,526 active participants. The plan reports 26,861 participants in total. So a bit more than half the people with money in this plan no longer work at TIAA. The $172,161 average balance reflects a long tenured workforce plus a large group of former employees who left their balances behind.
Investment options
The plan lists 36 options, and the lineup looks like what an insurance company would build for itself. You can see the whole menu on the investment options page.
The index core is BlackRock: BlackRock Equity Index for large cap U.S. stocks, BlackRock Mid Cap Equity Index, BlackRock Russell 2000 Index for small caps, BlackRock MSCI ACWI ex U.S. for international, and BlackRock U.S. Debt Index for investment grade bonds. CREF Equity Index R3 adds another broad U.S. index option. This is a solid, low cost skeleton, and four funds built from it cover most of what a long term saver needs.
The active sleeve is where the lineup gets unusual. There are CREF Stock, CREF Growth, CREF Global Equities and CREF Social Choice, plus AB U.S. Small and Mid Cap, Schroders International Multi-Cap, Wellington International, JPMorgan Equity Income R6, Vanguard Explorer Admiral, TIAA-CREF Core Plus Bond, TIAA-CREF High-Yield, TIAA-CREF Large-Cap Growth and TIAA-CREF Short-Term Bond. Money market options are CREF Money Market R3 and R4 and Vanguard Federal Money Market.
Three annuity sleeves sit at the bottom of the list: TIAA Traditional GSRA, TIAA Traditional RCP and the TIAA Real Estate Account. TIAA Traditional is a guaranteed contract. It pays a stated rate and accepts transfers out under rules that differ between the two contract versions, which is why the same product shows up twice. The Real Estate Account owns buildings directly, not REITs, and it is priced once a day rather than traded on an exchange. The account returned 1.48% in the second quarter of 2026 and 4.27% over the twelve months ending June 30, 2026. It also has a history of limiting withdrawals when too many people ask for money at once, so treat it as a long term sleeve and not as cash.
Two things to know before you pick. First, the CREF accounts are variable annuities, so they carry insurance charges on top of the investment expense. The list shows both R3 and R4 classes of CREF Stock, Core Bond, Growth, Global Equities, Social Choice and Money Market. Two share classes of the same portfolio normally means two fee schedules. Check which class your account is in. Second, most of this menu is TIAA’s own product. Fourteen of the 36 listings are CREF accounts, five are TIAA-CREF funds, two are TIAA Traditional contracts and one is the Real Estate Account. All of them come from the same company that keeps the records. That is normal for an insurer’s own plan, and it makes the annual fee disclosure the most useful document you have.
The lineup has no target-date series in it. The plan does publish a default investment account for people who never make an election. So a new hire who ignores the enrollment form ends up somewhere that is not a glide path. Ask HR what the default is and where your first contribution went. The gaps are small: no stand-alone emerging markets fund, though the ACWI ex U.S. index holds emerging markets inside it; no REIT fund, with the Real Estate Account as the property exposure; and no TIPS index fund, though CREF Inflation-Linked Bond R3 covers inflation protected bonds. A self-directed brokerage account is available for anything the menu does not carry.
Putting the funds to work over 20 years
A simple three fund build inside this plan would use BlackRock Equity Index for U.S. stocks, BlackRock MSCI ACWI ex U.S. for international stocks, and BlackRock U.S. Debt Index for bonds. Add TIAA Traditional in place of part of the bond sleeve if you would rather hold a stated rate than a bond fund that moves with interest rates. The plan page puts the average employee contribution of $5,978 a year at $382,645 after 20 years at a 10% annual return. The average employer match of $1,625 comes to $104,025 over the same stretch. Those two numbers next to each other make the case for saving past the match better than any argument.
You can test the same idea with real history instead of a projection. Our Core Two and Three Asset DCA calculator runs a simple stock and bond portfolio through the last 20 years with regular monthly contributions, using actual fund returns. Put the same asset mix into it that you would build from the BlackRock index funds above. Then you can see how the 2008 and 2022 drawdowns felt along the way, and what steady contributions did to the ending balance.
What happened at TIAA this year
On October 1, 2026, Nuveen, the asset manager owned by TIAA, completed its acquisition of Schroders. The combined firm reports about $2.6 trillion in assets under management, after a deal valued near $13 billion when it was announced in February. Schroders will run as a separate unit inside Nuveen for the next 12 to 18 months. The two plan to fold their roughly $400 billion of private markets business into one platform under a single chief investment officer, Saira Malik. TIAA chief executive Thasunda Brown Duckett called the combination central to the company’s lifetime income business. Schroders International Multi-Cap is one of the funds in this plan’s menu, so participants own a small piece of the story.
In February, TIAA and Nuveen said 1,000 employers across corporate, education, government and health care have adopted their target-date funds with lifetime income built in. That is the company’s fastest growing product line, and it is exactly the product this plan’s own menu does not offer its employees. If you want a target-date fund with a guaranteed income sleeve inside your 401(k), the brokerage window or a conversation with HR is the route.
The workforce news matters for participants who are still there. TIAA is closing its office at 1670 Broadway in Denver during 2026 and moving about 1,000 positions to a new corporate center in Frisco, Texas. That is three years before the lease runs out in 2029. The company cited savings in rent and operating costs. Employees were given the option to relocate. That is the kind of change that ends with people rolling balances out of the plan, and it is one reason the plan carries so many former employee accounts.
Bottom line
Put in at least 3% of pay. That is the whole match, and at the average active participant’s pay it is worth about $3,788 a year. A Roth 401(k) option is available, and the match is paid in dollars into the funds you choose, with no company stock involved. The match vests after three years of service, at age 65 or at death. So a short stay costs you the employer money, and that is worth planning around if you may leave before the three year mark.
The strongest part of this plan is price. At 1.14 basis points and about $43 per participant, there is almost nothing between your contribution and the market. The weakest part is the employer ceiling at 3% of pay, and the menu is built around TIAA’s own annuity products rather than a plain index lineup. Use the BlackRock index funds for the core, keep an eye on which CREF share class your account uses, and check the fee disclosure once a year. If you have already left TIAA, the rollover page for this plan lays out the choices for the balance you left behind.
