How MyPlanIQ Rates 401(k) Plans

MyPlanIQ compares 401(k) plans using public filings. The rating gives you a starting point to ask questions about your plan’s costs, employer contributions, and participant savings.

Which plans qualify?

We use Form 5500 and Schedule H data, positive reported assets, and usable cost, contribution, and savings inputs. Scorecards that show a participant size group compare similar plans in that group. The current release includes groups of 100–249, 250–999, and 1,000 or more active participants. The Top 20 lists compare published scorecards within each size group. The rank shown on a badge comes from the full scoring cohort, which can include plans without a published scorecard. We hold back inconsistent filings and cases that need identity review.

The overall rating requires all three component scores. The number of plans in the scoring group can be larger than the number with published scorecards.

How we calculate a rating

  • Plan cost (50%). We divide reported plan expenses by average plan assets and compare the result with other plans in the same filing year. Plans with lower reported costs receive a higher cost score.
  • Employer contributions (25%). We compare employer contributions per active participant and employer contributions relative to employee contributions. These figures can include profit sharing and other contributions. Check the plan terms for the actual match formula.
  • Participation and savings (25%). We use available measures of balances, contributions, and participant counts to compare savings across plans. Retired and separated workers can be included in the filing counts.

We combine the three scores on a 0–100 scale. For example, category scores of 80, 60, and 40 give an overall rating of 65. We show a rounded score in the summary and more precision in the details. Rank 1 is the highest overall score in the reported cohort. Plans tied at the benchmark’s scoring precision share the same rank.

The new participant benchmark selects one current filing per employer identification number and plan number. When the same period has multiple filings, we use the latest received filing. We omit final filings and set aside expenses below one basis point for review because the reported figure may omit material costs. Category inputs with equal values receive the same percentile. Older scorecards may still use an earlier filing-level comparison.

What the data can tell you

A filing describes a specific plan year. Current matches, investment options, and charges can differ. Some fees are deducted directly from participant accounts or reflected in investment returns. A plan that reports zero expenses does not necessarily charge zero fees, and we exclude it from the cost rating. Consult your current fee disclosure and plan documents for your own costs and benefits.

Scores can change when filings are amended, the comparison group changes, or we correct a data issue. The scorecard names the form year and, when available, the plan period and filing reference. The filing year identifies the version of Form 5500. A plan’s reporting period can differ.

Sources and corrections

We use the Department of Labor’s Form 5500 datasets and EFAST2 public filing search. The Department of Labor also explains how participants can check their fees.

The MyPlanIQ Data team maintains the scoring method and the MyPlanIQ editorial team reviews the participant-facing explanations. If a figure looks wrong, contact MyPlanIQ support with the scorecard URL and the public filing reference. Please leave out personal account information.

Method history

The 2024 participant benchmark retains the original 50%, 25%, and 25% weights and makes the comparison group and handling of ties explicit. A plan rating is a MyPlanIQ analysis of the public filing and does not provide individual investment or rollover advice.

Find a 401(k) plan rating