ETF Cloning of the Schwab VA
11/30/2010 0 comments
In a previous article noted that Variable Annuities have well chosen sub account funds that can lead to a portfolio that can deliver good returns. We now examine the Schwab Select Annuity, compare it with the Fidelity Personal Retirement Annuity and see how well an ETF clone performs
In Summary, the Fidelity Personal Retirement Annuity's plan consists of 56 funds. These funds enable participants to gain exposure to 5 major assets: US Equity, Foreign Equity, REITs, Emerging Market Equity and Fixed Income.
Asset Class |
Schwab |
Fidelity |
US |
35 |
13 |
International |
5 |
5 |
Sector |
3 |
12 |
Balanced |
2 |
8 |
Fixed income |
9 |
7 |
Emerging Markets |
1 |
3 |
Real estate |
1 |
1 |
Target Date |
0 |
7 |
We are now going to build a clone plan and see how it performs. We will simplify the choice and not duplicate styles.
US Funds
Style | Fidelity | ETF |
LARGE BLEND |
DGAGX KBCAX PIODX PJIAX SICWX SWHGX SWPPX |
VTI |
LARGE GROWTH |
AAGOX JGIIX NMTBX SDGAX |
VUG |
LARGE VALUE |
ACGMX ACSDX AVLIX KDCAX MEIIX |
VTV |
MID-CAP BLEND |
GMCBX GTAVX RMVSX SOPVX |
VO |
Mid-Cap Growth |
AMGOX BGRFX DFCIX TEGAX |
IJK |
Mid-Cap Growth |
FMCCX |
|
MID-CAP VALUE |
ABASX |
IJJ |
SMALL BLEND |
KDSAX |
VB |
Small Growth | PGOFX SIGWX SSDAX | VBK |
Small Value | CSSBX DEVLX FBVAX | VBR |
The US funds choice is very wide and here we will not mirror all the choices just one in each style category.
International Funds
Style | Fidelity | ETF |
World Stock |
JWGRX |
EFA |
World Stock |
OGLYX |
VT |
Similarly we will match one style in each category in the international asset class.
Emerging markets
Style | Fidelity | ETF |
Emerging Markets |
LZEMX |
EEM |
|
We select two emerging market ETF's to provide an alternative style.
Real Estate
Styles | Fidelity | ETF |
REAL ESTATE |
IYR |
IYR, RWX |
Real estate is under represented -- an international REIT would strengthen this asset class. We will add an international REIT Fund to the ETF's.
Fixed Income
Style | Fidelity | ETF |
Emerging Markets Bond |
MSIEX |
EMB |
High Yield Bond |
FHNIX |
HYG |
Inflation-Protected Bond |
PRRIX |
TIP |
Intermediate-Term Bond |
FBNDX |
BND |
Intermediate-Term Bond |
PTTRX |
|
Cash |
CASH |
CASH |
Short-Term Bond |
PTLDX |
SHY |
The fixed income class is well balanced with good choices and diversification. We match this with the exception of having a second intermediate term bond.
We are not attempting to match any of the balanced funds as there is no opportunity to use these in a standalone portfolio. While the managed funds are available, the fee structure is such that the returns are going to leak into other people's pockets and it will pay you to be on top of your own investments -- either directly or through a professional.
We now compare the returns of the two plans using tactical and asset allocation strategies with a moderate risk portfolio.
Performance chart (as of Nov 19, 2010)
Performance table (as of Nov 19, 2010)
Portfolio Name | 1Yr AR | 1Yr Sharpe | 3Yr AR | 3Yr Sharpe | 5Yr AR | 5Yr Sharpe |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fidelity Personal Retirement Annuity Tactical Asset Allocation Moderate |
16% | 113% | 9% | 78% | 15% | 115% |
Fidelity Personal Retirement Annuity Strategic Asset Allocation Moderate |
15% | 130% | 4% | 20% | 7% | 42% |
Fidelity-VA-Clone Tactical Asset Allocation Moderate |
10% | 69% | 7% | 58% | 10% | 75% |
Fidelity-VA-Clone Strategic Asset Allocation Moderate |
12% | 103% | 1% | 2% | 5% | 22% |
The Variable Annuity Portfolios have a clear lead over its ETF clone. The reason for this is the larger number of funds to allow styles rotation.
In fact, to get similar performance using ETF's, you would need to go to one of the richest plans -- provided by TD Ameritrade. The comparison is below.
Performance chart (as of Nov 19, 2010)
Performance table (as of Nov 19, 2010)
Portfolio Name | 1Yr AR | 1Yr Sharpe | 3Yr AR | 3Yr Sharpe | 5Yr AR | 5Yr Sharpe |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fidelity Personal Retirement Annuity Tactical Asset Allocation Moderate |
16% | 113% | 9% | 78% | 15% | 115% |
Fidelity Personal Retirement Annuity Strategic Asset Allocation Moderate |
15% | 130% | 4% | 20% | 7% | 42% |
TD Ameritrade Commission Free ETFs Tactical Asset Allocation Moderate |
11% | 77% | 12% | 78% | 19% | 117% |
TD Ameritrade Commission Free ETFs Strategic Asset Allocation Moderate |
8% | 74% | -0% | -5% | 7% | 37% |
One important note is that the returns are before fees are assessed. Variable annuities are complex instruments with fees that can be in excess of 2% of the asset base per year. Even so, the historical returns are good and there is the benefit that gains are not taxed.
Looking at the fund design for Variable Annuities can be instructive to allow you to build a plan that enables portfolios that give you good risk adjusted returns.
labels:investment,
Symbols:AGG,AOK,AOM,BIV,BND,BSV,CIU,CSJ,DBC,DBE,DBN,DBR,DBT,DBU,DEM,DES,DGG,DKA,DLN,DON,DPN,DRF,DSC,DWM,EEM,EFA,EFG,EFV,ELG,ELV,EMG,EMM,EMV,EXI,EZM,GBF,GII,GMM,GWL,HYG,ICF,IGE,IJH,IJJ,IJK,IJR,IOO,IP,IPF,IPW,ITE,IVE,IVV,IVW,IWM,IWP,IWR,IWS,IWV,IWW,IWZ,IXC,IXJ,IXP,
comments 0